Skip to content

Voices from the open internet

Opinion

The scoreboard is broken

The Trade Desk VP of Product Management Andrew Eifler argues that as Google and Meta capture an increasingly large share of global ad spend, the industry must rethink how it measures advertising effectiveness and whether those investments are growing businesses.

A scoreboard that says '404' sits on top of a laptop keyboard.

Illustration by Dave Cole / Getty / Shutterstock / The Current

By

VP, Product Management, The Trade Desk

November 16

If you take a step, way back, and look at it on a global level, what does the advertising industry look like?

The global advertising industry is enormous — approximately $1.2 trillion spent annually. Over the last 100+ years, advertising spend has generally grown on pace with GDP (about 2% per year currently). This means that when one type of advertising grows more than 2%, it’s at the expense of a different type. In other words, the biggest story in the industry over the last 20 years isn’t necessarily the growth of advertising overall, it’s the massive redistribution of where ad dollars are being spent.

And when you look at that redistribution, there are two very clear winners: Google and Facebook (now Meta).

In 2025, Google and Meta generated approximately $491 billion in advertising revenue, representing more than 40% of all advertiser spend globally. Ten years earlier, these two companies represented roughly 15% of the global market. In just 10 years, they went from capturing approximately one out of every seven ad dollars to more than two out of every five. If you include Amazon, these three companies now account for more than half of the global advertising market outside of China.

This represents one of the largest shifts in media investment in the history of advertising. Hundreds of billions of dollars have moved toward a small number of technology platforms, justified by a straightforward argument: digital advertising is more targeted, more measurable, and more effective at helping advertisers grow their businesses.

On the surface, that argument seems pretty compelling. Google and Meta have built sophisticated advertising platforms that reach billions of consumers and provide marketers with detailed reporting about the results of their investments. Their sales teams and marketing scientists work with advertisers around the world to demonstrate how their platforms are driving incremental sales and helping businesses grow.

But there’s an interesting question worth asking. During the same period that Google and Meta have captured such a dominant share of global advertising investment, what has happened to the businesses paying for all of these ads?

The brands aren’t growing 

Michael Farmer, an advertising industry consultant and author of Madison Avenue Manslaughter, has done some fascinating research on this topic. He analyzed the revenue growth of some of the largest advertisers in the world and found that many grew more slowly than GDP, while others experienced declining revenues. In one analysis, Farmer found that the combined revenues of P&G, Unilever, Nestlé, and Colgate-Palmolive (some of the largest advertisers in the world) grew approximately 1.1% annually between 2009 and 2024, roughly half the rate of GDP growth.

Meanwhile, Google and Meta are telling advertisers that their advertising is driving incremental business growth. Their reporting looks credible, their measurement is sophisticated, and their platforms are generating incredible financial results. But the businesses paying for the ads aren’t experiencing anything close to the same level of success. 

How can both of these things be true? 

The answer is: the way we’re measuring advertising is flawed — or, said differently: the scoreboard is broken.

The problem with measuring advertising

One of the greatest innovations of the walled gardens was their ability to control both the advertising environment and much of the measurement used to evaluate it. They could sell you the advertising, deliver it, measure it and then tell you how effective it was. This is the concept of grading your own homework, and it creates an enormous conflict of interest when the results determine where advertisers invest their money.

Historically, digital advertising relied heavily on last-click and last-touch attribution, which tend to favor platforms that interact with consumers toward the end of a purchase journey. A consumer might see a television advertisement, encounter a brand across several websites, and then search for the brand on Google before buying something. Under last-click attribution, Google gets the credit, even though the demand may have been created somewhere else.

Platforms have since developed more sophisticated measurement capabilities, but the fundamental conflict remains. When a platform controls the data, methodology and reporting used to evaluate its own effectiveness, advertisers have limited ability to independently verify the results.

We've seen this conflict produce real problems. In 2016, Facebook admitted it had 
overstated average video viewing times for approximately two years. In 2023, research 
from Adalytics raised concerns about Google's video advertising placements, suggesting some advertisements were delivered in environments that didn't meet advertisers' expectations. Google disputed those findings.

We’ve confused cheap reach with effective advertising 

Andrew Tindall at System1 has published fascinating research on the relationship between attention, emotion and advertising effectiveness. His work reinforces that delivering an advertisement is the same as creating advertising value. How long someone pays attention, how they respond emotionally, and whether they connect that response to the brand all matter. How long someone pays attention, how they respond emotionally, and whether they connect that response to the brand all matter.

Yet many digital advertisements receive extraordinarily little attention. Research cited by System1 suggests that 85% of digital ads fail to clear a 2.5-second attention threshold associated with memory. Meanwhile, the industry considers a display advertisement viewable after just one second, or a video advertisement after two seconds.

We've become incredibly good at buying impressions and demonstrating efficiency. I’m not sure we’ve become nearly as good at understanding whether those impressions actually create value. 

Everyone gets credit for the same sale

Consider someone buying a new car. Over several months, they see a connected television advertisement introducing the vehicle, see a few ads on a social app, and eventually use a search engine before visiting a dealership and buying the car.

Now consider how the various ad platforms used to buy those ads might report that transaction. The search engine says, “I sold that car, and it only cost you $1.25 cents for the click.”  The social app says, “I sold that car, and it only cost you $0.60.”  Then the DSP used to buy CTV ads says, “I sold the car, and it cost you $5.80 for the premium CTV ads you bought.”

The car advertiser evaluates these reports and concludes that search and social are producing more efficient returns.  Connected television appears expensive and difficult to measure, so the manufacturer reduces investment in CTV and reallocates toward search and social.

The following year, attributed marketing efficiency improves, but sales remain flat or decline. Management responds by demanding greater marketing efficiency, which drives further investment toward the channels reporting the highest returns. 

And the cycle repeats.

Fixing the scoreboard 

We need to fundamentally reconsider how the advertising industry defines success.

We need independent measurement that isn’t controlled by the companies selling advertising. We need to distinguish between demand creation and demand capture, recognizing that both are valuable but serve different purposes. We need to put greater emphasis on the quality of consumer attention, the time available to communicate a message, and the emotional impact of advertising rather than simply optimizing for cheap impressions.

And most importantly, we need to reconnect advertising measurement with the actual financial performance of the businesses paying for it.

The purpose of advertising isn’t to generate clicks, impressions, attributed conversions or attractive ROAS dashboards. It’s to help businesses grow.

The scoreboard is broken, and until we fix it, we’re going to keep optimizing for the wrong things. 

The Current is owned and operated by The Trade Desk Inc.

Subscribe to The Current

Industry news, expert analysis, behind-the-scenes podcasts and more—straight to your inbox.