Skip to content

Voices from the open internet

Opinion

Go where the attention is, and bring something worth seeing

Kargo CEO Harry Kargman writes that digital advertising needs an upgrade, and advertisers should meet consumers where they are.

Oasis in a browser window sitting atop a chaotic pile of ads.

Illustration by Robyn Phelps / Shutterstock / The Current

By

Founder and CEO, Kargo

November 19

Digital advertising needs an upgrade, or it will cease to be relevant.

More than 20 years ago, I created Kargo when I realized that the mobile phone would change the way we live, and the advertising business branching off of it should be just as impactful. We use phones all day — to work, communicate, solve problems, discover new products and shop — all on a small device that fits into our pocket. It was a total disruption.

Today, we’re in the middle of a similar disruption. People are surrounded by screens and AI content, but advertising hasn’t caught up. We need to meet consumers where they are.

But the industry is stuck in silos and not designed for impactful moments on every surface. Most digital advertising technology has not been engineered for attention. We’ve built systems around bid requests, and we push generic creative through a supply chain full of waste.

Our industry optimizes impression by impression and spends so much time finding audiences that we sacrifice the human connection that makes a story stick. To capture that attention, we need to reestablish that human connection and do it on a massive scale.

Pay attention

This should be the best time to be a marketer. Attention has shifted dramatically to digital screens, and brands have more ways than ever before to reach people where they are. But most brands have been frustrated by needless barriers amid an influx of bots on the web, unable to drive real results by chasing low-cost impressions.

Jounce Media’s research shows why cheap reach can be misleading: Made for Advertising (MFA) sites can post attractive viewability metrics without influencing purchase decisions. This, plus increasing signal loss, gives advertisers reasons to build brands and drive results by earning measurable attention.

We tend to overcomplicate the job by trying to game the system. The winning formula is actually simple: show up where people are spending their time, bring the right creative to that moment and use AI to make it work harder. A retailer can start with approved assets and show someone what is actually in stock nearby, in a format that fits the screen they’re using.

But AI can also produce the average ad at extraordinary speed. If we mistake that for progress, we will fill every screen with work nobody remembers.

Want to capture the attention that’s been lost in advertising? Ask the tough questions about exactly where and how your brand shows up across screens. Find the places where your message has room to make a human connection.

When attention is the goal, placement is just the first step. The second step is the creative itself, which is how outcomes are earned — from discovering a new brand to visiting a store and making a purchase.

Make the most of your time together

As AI summaries and chatbots reshape the search landscape, publishers face a challenge — and therefore, so do advertisers. In a Pew Research Center study, people clicked on a traditional search result in 8% of visits with an AI summary, compared with 15% of visits without one. We’ve all read a confident AI answer and wondered what it left out. People still want to go deeper on a topic, and when they reach a publisher's page, advertisers have the opportunity to create a moment.

Brands should go beyond a standard banner; for years, advertisers tried to deliver their messages into tiny rectangles that were barely visible on a smartphone. But impressions today must be high quality and artistic. Rather than try to fit into a preexisting box, brands should start where the audience is and deliver something worth experiencing. Someone reading a recipe could see an exciting new ingredient in an ad and add it to a cart at their preferred retailer in a click.

These concepts aren’t one-off, they are what work now. In a MediaScience and SmartCommerce lab study, people looked at shoppable formats for nearly twice as long as standard banners and recalled the brands at roughly twice the rate.

Takeovers and other high-impact formats give a brand room to tell a cohesive story or be highly memorable. That opportunity also exists in moments of transition, like a login page or the time someone spends using WeTransfer. Right now, I don’t believe programmatic is built to take an asset pack and adapt its content for all these surfaces at scale. This is how you deliver something worth seeing and remembering.

The same asset pack could become a takeover on mobile and desktop. It could appear on an order confirmation page, when someone pauses a show or at the end of a streaming program. Pause ads and Slate ads are built for these moments.

Big screen experiences can be just as creative; the fifteen-second spot is only a starting point today. Streaming gives us new ways to create that focus, and we can measure whether it happens. In a TVision study, Kargo’s enhanced CTV creative held viewers’ attention 30% longer than standard creative. For a media buyer, the question is how much of the audience actually looked at the screen. Our focus on attention has pushed us to invent experiences for moments the industry never thought to design for.

Until now, much of that access has been available to enterprise brands and large agencies with enterprise budgets, but AI eliminates that barrier. Kargo is putting the power of incredible advertising in the hands of businesses of any size, and we hope it’s just as valuable to publishers as it is to brands that were previously limited to the walled gardens. A growing brand can begin with the assets it already trusts and build campaigns across streaming and online video, and publishers get new demand, driving up the value of their site.

If you’re going to pay for attention, you need to earn that attention with the time you have together.


This op-ed represents the views and opinions of the author and not of The Current, a division of The Trade Desk, or The Trade Desk. The appearance of the op-ed on The Current does not constitute an endorsement by The Current or The Trade Desk.

Subscribe to The Current

Industry news, expert analysis, behind-the-scenes podcasts and more—straight to your inbox.